My Blog List

Friday, August 29, 2014

A week is long time in politics: Reaching self through World !



by me, 5th June 2014
========================


It is often said that a week is a long time in politics, and truly yes, it is. As demonstrated by historic mandate India gave to one party, one leader in particular, this is truer than before. The scale of analysis, introspection and obsession with critical scrutiny these election results received are unparalleled in recent Indian history. Only comparisons, if they fit, can be Mandal-Kamandal debate in 1990s and lately the anti-corruption movement and gender sensitive legislations in last two years. The week after 16th May seems to have not only shocked the intellectual foundations of the media, academia and intelligentsia but also have uprooted the deep contradictions within so called ‘Secular-Progressive-Liberal’ establishments across the country. Some are trying to stick to age old political ideologies of sycophancy, some to ‘hippocratic’ salesmanship of secularism and some to ‘lip-service’ of inclusive diversity of a country which never allows the dictum of dogma, division and duplicity.  

My week followed by election results gave me few insights about the issues which not only unshackled my imagination but also gave me a window of opportunity for making sense of the things in coming times. On a summer full of heat waves, I happen to travel to sea-faced temple of meditation in Mumbai. Temple, not in a religious sense, but surely in a spiritual-meditative sense. This is a grateful tribute returned by Satynarayan Goenka to his Gurus from Myanmar for gifting India the art and knowledge of Vipassana. His guru was Saya Gyi U Ba Khin, who recently for decades pursued the knowledge of Vipassana and distributed the same to thousands of followers through international Vipassana Meditation Centres established in Myanmar. Saya Gyi predicted that next revival of Dhamma will be from India and one Indian will be responsible for carrying out massive explorations and journey for spreading this knowledge to poor and ignorant without any greed, without religious bias and without any materialistic motive. This person was Satyanarayan Goenka. In the darkness of history, this art and science of life-meditation was lost in the corridors of ignorance. So, I was fortunate to embark on this short journey. So short in distance, but so long in meaning, investigation and acquiring the wisdom that I still don’t consider myself worthy for the reward of that journey, let alone the claim that I understood the whole import of that philosophy.

I reached Global Vipassana Pagoda in search of questions and not for answers. Questions, which can destroy me, questions that can recreate me. Questions that can shake my foundations, questions that can construct vision of my life. Questions that can heal my vitiated mind, questions which can sharpen my intellect and argument. Questions which can awaken me from my slumber—which in its extreme insensitivity have insulted many virtues and in effect---bypassed many struggles, many voices, many movements throughout the life I lived or claimed to live upon to. Many times we search for answers where our questions are wrongly placed, inspired by narrow vision and shaped by parochial dreams. So, I was in search of questions which should propel my life forward through which I can travel and struggle, fight and die while finding answers to them. Why, how, when all the biggest challenges destroy me and appeal me with its cruel charm that hello, show your pain and stand up again; so that I can say with pride, “Yes, I am ready to take on my Conqueror” and let me feel the pain, poverty and pity in myself while watching through the eyes of aggressor. While I concentrate and focus my gaze to the undisturbed pose of the hegemonic time in front of me, I say to it: “you may be infinite, but I am finitely minuscule, deep down to my existence and mind well; my impatience, my greed, my insensitivity, my utter contempt for public service are also finite---will be destroyed by presence of infinite failures, agony of shameful defeats and all pervasive fall of my character time and again. So, come on you infinite, I finite, is ready to face you. So, come on!!!”

I have been to Vipassana dhyan once in my early university days. While I did not formally enrolled again in due course of last few years; I continue to meditate on my own what I consider the one of the greatest gifts I have received in my mortal life. But I never viewed it from the point of view of “Liberating Force” for ignorant, poor and marginalized. As I reached the place, beyond sea of Gorai, near Assel World; people started coming in slowly but steadily. Initially, there were clear herds were going to entertainment park near Pagoda. As sun started climbing, the number of groups and people started ascending. I underestimated the magnetic potential of the place. It had more people on weekdays than normally what one tourist place attracts on weekends, bookshop owner told me during my visit.

The way people have received it is astounding. Even though, it is not a typical religious place and does not support the traditional rituals of religion; this place has emerged as one of the few places in India which can advocate social-political reform, quest of knowledge-scientific attitude, virtues of social commitment and community service, dedication to questioning attitude and readiness to bulldoze the burden of faith and its claim that surrender to god, together all potentially can give us the calm, peace and solutions. Instead, this Pagoda—epitome of self criticism and tower of service towards self-society through wisdom, compassion and  inclusiveness—has emerged as a symbol of not only peace amongst different religions, in its essential goal of “establishing supremacy of humanism”; but also has projected the vision of  “Equanimity”. This equanimity, as epitomized in the preaching of Gautam Buddha in the form of Dhamma. Buddha never claimed to have founded the religion. Even some kind of consolidation of culture being lived by people, who follow Buddhism, is being formalized over the years; it was never visualized by Buddha as a ritualistic religion which can satisfy our cravings for compensating piousness with rewards, both material and spiritual.
Vipassana, was essence of Buddhism; historically. During the course of time, when Buddhism lost the path and also the wisdom of the meditation, it started dwindling. Art of Viapassana was scientific way of aligning our life with rational principles of nature and thus immerse ourselves in consistent self-reflection about the changes in ourselves and around us. These changes—sometimes pleasant and many times unpleasant—always disturb our composure---makes us happy in pleasant times and sad in sorrow times. Vipassana through meditation with an equanmious mind glorifies the vulnerability of life but also illuminates the massive potential of Sthitpradnya; uncollapsable silent-steady-solid attentive power of mind in any situation---and thus escorts us through the corridors of mind-body-brain triangle. From there, it leaves our hand thus we are on our own to explore, investigate and rediscover our lost control, our disappeared conscience, our languishing-perishing-corroding selfishness and we thus slowly arrive at the gates of comradeship, friendship, entrepreneurship of values. 

This entrepreneurship does not talk of wealth creation but discusses long lasting virtues, values and assets. The relations we make with people all our lives have unique potential to solve the problems around us. But we alienate many and get obsessed with remaining. The emotions, rather than being strengths become self inflicting swords and further our self-character becomes obstacle rather than engine of dissent. Our personality becomes symbol of greed instead of energetic commitment to welfare. Our life gets reflected as a stagnant supporter of slavery to power rather than transformer of lives suffering from poverty of arguments, hunger of food and vacuum of knowledge.

So, this Dhamma which is eternally simple in its purely natural form has been essential representation of Buddhist way of life i.e. Buddhism.  This Pagoda is not only a memorial of what Myanmaar did to preserve this heritage and knowledge of Vipassna but also putting Life of Buddha in right perspective in today’s times of intolerance, greed and technologically pervert times when we refuse to talk to each other and rather satisfied in gadgets while being insular from pain in front of us. This is a memorial to people who stood for human rights, who fought for equality and who lived and died for freedom from slavery, from ignorance and from caste system, from class system, from political system of prejudice-bias. This is a symbol of perseverance of people who stay calm in the events of crisis, in the agony of oppression and during the times of deprivation. This is homage to Bikshus and Bikshunees who stood for justice and progress during the times of conservative onslaught of religion. This is a structure which is a salute to the exploration of people who wanted to understand what exists inside life, what happens during life and why is it so. This is not about life beyond death; heaven and hell. This is about understanding why we create multiple worlds for same people, divergent dreams for fellow compatriots and divisive ideology for harmonious life---existing for all, nurturing all and shaping us all—together, in tough times, in simple times.

While going through the biography of Buddha, while listening to the story of how this Pagoda was created and while watching what different aspects of Vipassana Buddha preached, it was clear that this is a way forward in life---not to pray, but to act and spread the message of self-discovery, service and sacrifice through exploration, introspection and debate.

That’s the feeling I got when I traveled a small journey but completed a longer process of reaching myself through Pagoda, Vipassana and Buddha.
====================================================================
rahul mane, (09654093359, creativityindian@gmail.com)                                                               ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sunday, June 8, 2014

Money, Media & Politics: Stenography to Power

Excerpts from lecture of P. Sainath (Editor: Agriculture & Rural Affairs, The Hindu) delivered at Venkatesh Chapalgaonkar Memorial Awards at Symbiosis, Pune on 6th June 2014

(Acknowledgement and thanks to Electronic Media Association, Pune ) 
====================================================

Money, Media and Politics: Understanding Stenography to power
By P. Sainath

Indian press is child of freedom struggle of India. Gandhi, Ambedkar, Tilak were great journalist who were use to print newspapers, magazines, journals. Even though number of printed copies or circulation of these publications was merely in thousands, but kind of impact it had on masses, on contemporary peers in media and on imperial government was unparalleled in history. Unfortunately, in today’s times, difference between journalism, public relations and stenography is becoming less and less.


Greatest speech in Indian history is unarguably that of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar in Constituent Assembly: “We have given country Political Democracy but have we given country and its citizens the economic and social equality and democracy? If not, the tension is to be created in future because of impending inequality and thus the democracy is going to explode.” 

Media, supposedly fourth estate of democracy--is most undemocratic in its social representations, about transparency regarding its accounts and on its accountability towards the society they belong to. Today’s media is politically free but is imprisoned by profit. Not all media houses are party to this crime but increasing corporatisation, influence of neoliberal transactions within transnational MNCs which are acquiring media houses and the deep running connivance between different power structures are forcing the Americanisation of Indian media—is truly dangerous to Indian democracy.


To understand how media behaves one has to understand how corporates function because media is no longer singular in approach, linear in interests and traditional in its nature of operation. It has become so dynamic, finance driven, politically complicit and morally bankrupt about its role towards society that one cannot imagine how far the naked arrogance of its owners has travelled that they are not in news business but in advertising space. 

Beyond technological convergence, today’s media mark the convergence of elitist morality, indifferent conscience and inequitable economic vision for citizens and country at large. In a way, as Prabhat Patnaik has described “Moral Universe of Media has shifted away from people” and essentially “media seems to be more powerful when sided with powerful.” Normally, it does not like to stand against power. Whatever results come, they come due to individuals who fight risking their lives, reputation and independence.

Revolving doors in corporates, media and governments are creating not only permanent vested interests but also shaping structures nurturing sustainable culture of endless greed in our lives through different products they offer through media industry. Collusion amongst politics, corporates and big media does not care about the issues which really free, independent press needs to address. Today`s media is primarily hostage to Advertisers, Hollywood, Cricket/Celebrities/Corporate for its content and revenue, forcing audiences to chew only that.

Corporatisation of Media is creating new powerful monopolies of media houses not only in print, electronic media but also in digital domain. In fact, issue of monopoly is even more serious in digital world as only seven companies are controlling the internet in one way or another. Concentration of corporate, political interests in media industry is so intrinsically deep rooted that there is now little space for the problems of people to be discussed. In fact, all the major scams exposed recently are either done by constitutional bodies like CAG, ED or by small newspapers-magazines. Mainstream media, as we know it today, is falling behind in terms of raising questions, ensuring follow up of pertinent crucial issues needed to be addressed in real time through investigative journalism.  

Fight against monopoly is not only grave issue in India but also in Europe, USA. In fact, USA has a great tradition of anti-monopoly legislations dating back to 1920s and 1930 when monopoly of Rockefeller brothers and Hollywood was broken to create a competition friendly environment. Increasing insensitivity in media can be gauged from the fact that major or almost all mainstream media houses are slowly relinquishing beats or portfolio from its reporting/editing work related to rural, poverty, labour, and development issues. This is very disturbing trend considering major chunk of population in India is poor, labour driven, working in unorganised sector and struggling to get basic amenities of life they deserve to be getting from government.

So we have arrived at the stage where media is not only becoming conglomerate itself but also is becoming one of the arms of big, bigger MNCs who does not care about spirit of journalism and its role in society like ours. This is primarily because goals today’s corporate media espouses, dreams it instigates and vision it inspires is that of deep inequality in society and not of democratic socialism which our founding forefathers/foremothers have envisioned for us. This was imagined in directive principles of state policy stated in Constitution. It is often said that “We should speak truth to power. Time has come when we should ask ourselves: “Whether it is necessary to speak truth to power or shall we speak truth about power, which is increasingly being suppressed, diverted and abused by people who illegitimately benefit from silence. So, the process through which we can defend our rights, more broadly ‘Bill of Rights’ so as to describe, should be strengthened and this process can be revitalised through democratic protests, organising the voice of dissent and finally by giving voice to people who want their stories to be reported, written, recorded, screened, photographed, printed, aired. Larger people participation in documentation, journalism and broadcasting will ensure this pressure to COMPELL MEDIA TO BEHAVE so as to carry on the legacy of freedom fight and Freedom Press of that era which cared for fundamental issues of human lives, development, dignity and human rights.

Transcribed roughly by Rahul Mane, creativityindian@gmail.com, 09654093359 
================================================================

Resources:
a) Summary of Paid News Report:
http://presscouncil.nic.in/OldWebsite/CouncilReport.pdf

b) How original report was suppressed:
http://www.outlookindia.com/article/Paid-News-The-Buried-Report/266542 

c) Original Report comes in full on Press Council of India website
http://presscouncil.nic.in/Content/139_5_Reportsonpaidnews.aspx 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Thursday, March 13, 2014

‘Liberating Structures’—Towards Unseen, Unheard, Unsaid…



 Reflections from Prof. Arvind Singhal`s workshop (February 2014, Ahmedabad)


In many ways, title of this approach bears feeling of oxymoron/paradox. At the first instance, liberating from any structure demands escape velocity. So you can imagine, how far the initiative to start discussion regarding it is challenging. It is a quest of learning in various problem situations of life. How to define problems, how to contextualize them and how to arrive at consensus to start working on it to move towards solution.

It is our common experience that “We are not good at designing conversations or interactions.” In a meaningful conversation, time slows down, doubts are cleared and we feel at home as far as expressing our confusions, problems are concerned. Essentially, in a group what we are trying to do is, to arrive at the same level of understanding (without feeling negating cognitive dissonance about it). So, small details of how interactions are designed—matter.


Abraham Lincoln, when he was on filed-tour during war of Northern and Southern states of USA, met soldiers on one of the front lines. One soldier when taken aback because of Lincoln’s height, asked him, how tall are you? He replied, “My son, my feets are tall enough to reach ground.” So, what this story indicates is—how shedding baggage of power and authority is crucial, if we wish to create connections to listen to each other. There are always lots of parallel conversations happening around. So drawing from the seeds spread around those conversations will help us not only to relate to us, but also learn from those. In liberal conversations, we should always take care to observe what kinds of spaces are created. People, audiences, consumers are comfortable in articulating in safer spaces. These safer spaces are designed in a way to promote and motivate active listening—willingness to listen. 

It is because of these patient, other centered interactions one is able to realize how perception of same thing is similar/dissimilar. How commonalities are reinforced? How different patterns emerging, are observed? In many interactions, “One nature of expression is different than that of other colleague`s nature of expression.” Because of the interactions, which are organized in a way different than traditional, tendency to hold on to our own idea is challenged and gets shattered. We learn to enjoy to add, share and collaborate. We start innovating combination of thoughts and experimenting with adaptations to external ideas, thoughts.  


Traditionally we are hard wired for patterns. We are poor at analyzing because we connect better to emotional self and emotional social. So it is always necessary to be compassionate towards self and towards other, while expressing and listening to others. This gives an emotional/humanistic orientation to dialogue with self and others. So, there always need to have effect to be always present: across activities, across groups, across levels and across functions in listening mode, in observation mode, in learning mode. 

It is after all, struggle of data vs patterns. In many ways, stories are beautiful form of data. Whenever we meet, interact, converse: we need to encourage each other to tell the stories. Stories give us authentic first person and multifaceted perspective about the personality, life and times. Stories expand and inspire our imagination and also allow us to develop emotional connect.

Different ways through which ‘conversations’ are done liberates participation for everyone. Then, after we invite people to repeat their stories, our understanding about reality deepens. Always make sure to invite, appeal others to contribute to stories. Listening, sharing and adding emphasize power of loose connections. We are bound by ‘Occupational Psychosis’. Our mental abilities, skills, vision are constrained by cognitive patterns evolved due to kind of life we lived, nature of struggle of survival we are in and type of work we do for living. For example, “For hammer everything is a nail.” ‘Interjectional structures are ubiquitous’, only thing is that we don’t make use of that. Our worldview about ‘interaction’ can be summarized out of our vision about education. “We never really attain students, we teach them.” 

Managed discussions are dangerous for creativity. Conventional structures stifle inclusion and engagement. Meetings, discussions, classrooms are full of disengaged, dysfunctional groups and wasted ideas. Innovative interventions in conversations may introduce novelty and freshness in ideas; make the process of engaging with stakeholders more reflective and exploratory to scout for new possibilities.  Traditional presentations and conversations need to go beyond ‘over-controlled’, ‘too-uniform’, ‘engaging only few in a group’ and ‘targeted only at formal event’ stereotypes. They need to be more process driven rather than rigid understanding about ‘output’ in a material sense. Open discussions involve, accommodate ‘under-controlled’, are flexible with unstable relationships, provide freedom to enter conversation at any point of time, give liberty to take any direction of thought. 

In many ways, approach towards ‘liberating structures’ is shaped in a distributed control through diverse yet interdependent relationships. Here, direction of conversation is shaped by participants themselves. This empowers and enables ordinary people to express what they have found better (or even extraordinary) solutions to existing problems—against all odds—without access to any extra resources. This process also thus respects and adheres to ‘Collective Wisdom’ to solve problems. It delivers better outcomes by recognizing outliers. Thus emerges ‘positive deviance’, perfected over a time though accumulation of small-incremental outlier acts. 

Example: COffice Hours-- Students can guide each other at open session organized by teachers at cafeteria-canteen. They maintain cohort relationships—that is a major resource. They also recruit each other. They reciprocate each other. Thus, creating conditions to connect through informal venues crucial by talking to people you don’t know.

So, creating conditions for help is important. This is new kind of empathetic-sympathetic-compassionate culture. Traditionally, we are not good at asking for help and also not good at helping each others. Thus, these kinds of interactions also induce transformations into self. This gives comfort-belief that yes; there is somebody to help. Communication is mostly non-verbal. It helps us to know what we perceive to be a problem, is not exactly that felt by us. It also makes it easier to live by knowing that we are not only one who has problems. Usually problems are never what they seemed to be. In this kind of interaction, an individual goes through 'listener-clarifier-adviser' mode giving ‘value addition of being stranger’ to a person seeking help. What is newly being suggested is practical, easy to follow and with absolutely least cost with certain empathy. Tolerance with some genuine urge to help coming out with responsibility—which is founding principle of this relationship. In short, whatever the problem—there is always a better, alternate solution dispersed in prospective conversations, we normally fail to explore. What we need, just to look around—see, listen, ask, interact, discuss—in a way different than we use to do, different than traditionally rigid way.
===========================================

Friday, March 7, 2014

"Grass in the Air"…Breeze from STUDIO 7


                                             "Grass in the Air…"


                       ================================================

“God respects me when I work, 
but God loves me when I sing--- Tagore”

I recalled above lines by legendary artist, when I started to realize what music, and especially one other than film music can do to me. Even though, I was only, like an illiterate person cravingly absorbed whatever coming at my way; it was an experience making me feel like an hungry-thirsty traveler wandering or lost in desert or in hills or in deep inside forest; greedily swallowing what is being thrown at it`s way through notes, scores, compositions, lyrics and vibrant frequencies.

What happened to our folk music? Where are the songs I used to listen to in my childhood in my mother tongue?  Where are the classic-classical songs I used to enjoy on Vividhbharti? Where are the rare records which I could not collect or preserve or get access to? Where are the insights which I need to have, whenever I am listening to particular genre? I am grappling with all these questions always and also get overwhelmed by whirlwind of this feeling which exhausts me when I don’t understand any beats, let alone Beatles, Metals, Led....Pink…Blues…Green...Black...  But, then someday, I become restless to search for answers to these questions once ambassadors of music inspire me to listen to music I have not listened uptill now. These ambassadors are Studio 7.

Thus, as I start my journey to enjoy songs and music, I don`t really know when I am enlightened by it and when I am completely seduced by it to forget myself to immerse completely in it; I don’t know. Because, I am completely indifferent to many types of music I am listening to. Many ways of songs; in terms of language, meanings; in form—western, classical, rock, blues, jazz, country, folk, Hindustani, Karnataki, street music, tribal music, pop, fusion, rap, hip-hop etc; In speed—slow, medium, fast, hypersonic, subtle, crazy-zigzag, tricky hide-and-seek scores, spiritually encircling to catch hold of our mind, exploding our bodies with radioactive energy and rhythmic-harmonious prayer entering my mind to make me more calm, authentically reflective and honestly sincere in trying to understand what after all is being played.

I don’t know what is happening to me but it is not less than what I feel like I am transformed into a bundle of grass in air after I am exposed here to music by all of you and by Studio7.
Grass—humble enough to withstand in the flood of arrogance, complacency and claim of expertise.
Grass—with same equanimity—‘coming back to life’ in green color--in every season, either spring, winter and monsoon.
Grass in the air—delicate, vulnerable, dwarf—but equally determined to devote, surrender and burn itself to give joy to everyone around through its fragrance, through its wise innocence, through its dedicated entanglement with soil—it helps to keep myself connected to ethos of history which inspired psychological undercurrents in people—who discovered different religion of music altogether—leaving all others like us to enjoy, marvel at, to become mad for it, to melt our lives to understand it and to dive deep in the seconds/minutes/hours for grasping true nature of it.
That makes me live this life, again and again. And nothing else, trust me!!!



“….singing in the dead of night
Take these broken wings and learn to fly
All your life, you were only waiting for this moment to arise.” 
                                                                                       (----Blackbird)  

Studio 7: Rock on, March on!!!

regards
rahul mane, (an ignorant fan !)
===========================================================

Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Community Radios: Inspiring Models of Globalisation + Localisation




World Radio Day was recently celebrated by UNESCO (13th February) and this time they have come up with (guess what ::)) a toolkit for radio producers working with children and youth.

UNESCO has also launched a campaign "EMPOWERING LOCAL RADIOs with ICTs"
 
Lines of Action
http://en.unesco.org/radioict/lines-action

RadioICT:
http://en.unesco.org/radioict/local-radios
 
http://en.unesco.org/radioict/icts  (especially please check this one)


====================================================